|
This is me singing. |
I am a singer. I have sung forever and I love it. On many occasions I openly attribute singing with saving my life and keeping me sane. Because, unlike other instruments, singing comes from somewhere deep in ones soul, singing gives voice to emotions in a way which playing an external instrument can not. Every vocal instrument has it's own unique sound, which is perhaps why people get so nervous about singing. Yet people have sung since forever, for countless reasons and for no reason at all. Everyone can sing, and most people do at some point in their lives. But a real 'singer' is someone who sings all the time, who feels sad if they don't sing for a day or so, who sings along to everything simply because that's what they do, they literally can't help it. Singing is a part of them and a part of what they do. For a singer, the act of
really singing, is freedom in it's purest form.
I want my daughter to sing, I can't wait to hear her voice when she does. Sometimes I sit her on my lap at the piano and sing songs which she sometimes 'sings' along to. Ok, so she might make more of a drawn out "aaaah" sound, but I like to think she's joining in. She certainly seems to be enjoying it.
But, much as I want her to be a singer, to get lessons, join choirs and to sing all that she can, I am worried. Because it has been my experience, that singers, are the most judgemental of all the musicians. Of those judgemental singers, the most bitchy are the trained singers, and strangely enough, the most arrogant, are the ones who have "never had a lesson".
This is an interesting paradox which I have come across time and time again, and am finding increasingly frustrating.
So why is this post on my 'mummy' blog?
Because this is a future my daughter is very likely to be entering into, and while I'll be thrilled if she does turn out to be a 'singer', the thought of her becoming this judgemental makes me sad, and thought of the judgement coming her way makes my stomach turn.
Let me explain.
We judge each other for singing too softly, having too much air in our tone, or not having enough breath support.
For being too tense, too slouchy, putting an H before a vowel, for putting a glottal stop before a vowel, for singing the same vowel different ways, for singing all the vowels the same.
For over singing, under singing, not enough diction or for over pronouncing words.
We judge other singers for not interpreting the song 'correctly', for not singing loud enough, for being too nasal, for not using enough nasality.
For yelling, for using too much vibrato, for not having vibrato or for not holding that final note quite as long as we could have held it.
We sit in polite silence when someone gets the solo that
'should have been ours',
and whisper to the singer next to us about how we can't stand the way another singer sings.
When a successful singer 'screws up' their live performance, my facebook page becomes riddled with comments about how useless they are. If a performer gets outed for singing to a click track, everyone starts talking about how they can't sing. If a new singer appears out of nowhere and shoots to fame, singers everywhere start to tear them down, to dish out backhanded criticisms:
"I'm sure they are a really nice person, but they really can't sing."
"What a horrible voice."
"Can't you hear their vibrato? It's terrible!"
"Omg, I can't stand the way they have no tone."
"They must have really rich parents, because there's no way they got where they are because of their voice."
It seems ridiculous to me, that when singers share such a visceral and primal need to use our voice for song, and can understand each other in a way non-singers can not, that we continue to sit on our high horses, acting as though we alone, are the be all and end all of musical taste and knowledge and know-how. That somehow
we are the voice above all others, and are not only
able to, but feel that we
should ensure, that everyone else knows that
they. are. not.
I have now been teaching singing for four years, and I have been taught different singing techniques by numerous different teachers over nearly 20 (yikes, really?!) years. I am not a perfect singer, but you know what? I don't know what a perfect singer is. There are very few people who come through my door who aren't as passionate about singing as I am. Who don't live and breath singing, and who haven't come to me because they are searching for something they know they have but can't find. To sing higher, louder, stronger, longer.
I do know, that for years and years my voice was trapped inside me because of fear, lack of training (yes, that hideous thing that means I cannot say my voice is 'my own' and unaltered), and general lack of belief. I knew that I could sing better than I was singing, but I struggled for years to actually find it. Sometimes I even dreamed that I was singing with nothing holding me back, that I had finally learnt how to free it. And when I finally found the teacher who was able to show me how to unlock it, I finally felt that feeling of utter freedom, and knew that finally, I found my true voice.
MY.
TRUE.
VOICE.
So when another singer brings someone else down for using their true voice, it makes my skin crawl.
Does it matter if someone is successful and 'making it' in a singing career if they do things less than perfect? Does it matter if they have a breathy tone or a husky voice? Does it matter if they never sing above a G4 or use too much vibrato? They are the ones who have 'made it'. They are the ones who have achieved what every, single, one of us dreams of. Why must we make ourselves feel better by convincing ourselves that we are more worthy of their success than they are?
What about you 'untrained' singers who make the self righteous claim 'I've never had a lesson' repeatedly, as though having a lesson means you are less of a true singer. Does having a singing lesson mean your voice is no longer pure? No longer your own? Does it mean that you don't deserve success because clearly you couldn't sing to start with?
What gives you, the trained or untrained singer down the road, the right to say this about anyone else?
"I'm sorry, but they just can't sing."
Really? They can't sing? What do you mean when you say that? More importantly, why are you saying it?
I sing because I love it and I have a need to do so.
I took lessons because I knew my true voice wasn't yet free and I wanted to find it.
I would rather die than be made to stop singing. It's a part of me. Just as it is a part of every singer.
So why can't we all stop talking behind each others backs, and start singing to each others faces?